Research

How Hong Kong Filmmaking Turns Precarity into Indebted Labour

Critique of creative labour: indebtedness and subsumption of labour in Hong Kong’s filmmaking industry
Ngai Pun, Haocheng YangDialectical Anthropology30/04/2025journal-article
filmster-network

Summary / Abstract

Pun and Yang ask how precarious freelance work persists in a highly specialised, capital-intensive film industry. They develop the concept of “indebted labour” through a study of filmmaking in Hong Kong, drawing on Marxist theories of labour subsumption and debates about the relationship between capital, production and workers’ autonomy. Their use of the term is distinct from bonded labour, which involves forced work to repay debt, and agency labour, which concerns workers placed through intermediaries.


The research draws on 45 semi-structured interviews conducted in 2023 and 2024 with filmmakers recruited through snowball sampling. Participants worked across film, documentary, streaming and advertising, in pre-production, production and post-production; the sample also included trade-union representatives. The authors identify three recurring dimensions of indebtedness: delayed or missing payment, workers’ responsibility for owning and maintaining production equipment, and the social obligations involved in preserving networks for future work.


Their argument is that these conditions reinforce one another. Outsourcing can pass financial risk down from investors to production companies and individual workers. Freelancers may advance costs, wait months for payment, and maintain professional relationships despite disputes because those relationships can lead to future employment. The authors describe this as financial, social and ideological indebtedness. They argue that the Hong Kong case challenges assumptions that advanced, specialised industries necessarily move towards more secure employment, and suggest that the concept may also help examine labour relations in platform-based work.

Read the Paper

Read the Paper

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10624-025-09774-y

Observations

The article’s main contribution is its account of indebtedness as a production relation with financial, material and social dimensions. The term brings together experiences that are often discussed separately: waiting for wages, financing work expenses, buying and maintaining equipment, and preserving ties to people who may offer the next job. The authors use this framework to examine how freelance autonomy can coexist with dependence on investors, production companies and informal hiring networks.


The argument is grounded in 45 interviews across different screen-work roles and production stages. The participants’ accounts make the proposed mechanisms concrete, including the practice of advancing money for production purchases and the reluctance to pursue arrears when doing so could damage future work relationships. The paper also situates these accounts within Hong Kong’s labour protections, industry structure and public funding context. That combination gives the analysis a clear institutional setting, while showing how workers’ day-to-day choices are shaped by wider conditions.


The study is exploratory. Snowball recruitment through the researchers’ networks can overrepresent people connected to those networks, and the interviews cannot establish how prevalent delayed payment or other conditions are across the entire sector. The broad definition of filmmaking includes advertising, television and streaming work as well as film, which supports analysis of transferable labour practices but leaves some differences between those markets less distinct. The paper would be strengthened by comparison across occupations, production types or jurisdictions, and by evidence from contracts, payment records or production-company accounts.


The concept also carries analytical weight across very different experiences. Wage arrears, equipment costs and the pressure to maintain relationships may all contribute to precarity, yet they work through different mechanisms and may call for different remedies. The authors make a persuasive case that these conditions can reinforce one another in Hong Kong. Further comparative research could clarify where “indebted labour” explains those connections especially well, and where the term risks grouping distinct problems under a single metaphor.

Relevance to Filmster

This paper adds a labour and political-economy perspective to Filmster’s research library. The previously selected work on collaborative expertise examined how creative authority and practical knowledge are distributed across a film crew. Pun and Yang shift the focus to the conditions under which screen workers sustain careers: payment delays, personal expenditure on equipment, outsourced production chains and the social cost of challenging a hirer. That makes this a distinct contribution to the archive’s account of filmmaking as both creative practice and work.


For Filmster.ID, the research raises a useful question about what a professional record can reveal. A verified credit can document participation and attribution; by itself, it says little about whether a worker was paid promptly, carried production costs or relied on a particular network to secure work. This is an editorial implication of the paper, not a finding about Filmster’s current product. It suggests a research question for future study: how might professional histories preserve context about working conditions without making sensitive employment information public by default?


For Filmster Studio and Reel Sense, the article offers concepts that could inform research into production relationships and knowledge representation. Future investigations might examine how records of hiring, expenses, equipment ownership, payment milestones and project changes could help describe where production risks accumulate. The paper does not test software or propose a digital system; any product application would require separate research with filmmakers, attention to privacy, and safeguards against treating incomplete records as proof of misconduct.

The better way
to make films